MemberClicks vs. campai: Choose the AMS edition before comparing.
MemberClicks Professional and MemberClicks Trade address different association needs. An alternative search should begin with the edition you use and whether memberships belong to individuals or organizations. This report keeps that distinction visible when comparing dues, member access, events, and optional engagement products. For clubs with 1,000+ members, campai offers a stronger fit for complex operations through large-club experience, advanced features, and integrations.
campai GmbH publishes this comparison and sells one of the products being compared. It draws on product documentation, help articles, and documented campai capabilities. We did not conduct an independent hands-on test.
What matters for your shortlist
For clubs with 1,000+ members, campai is the stronger choice when your staff needs flexible member workflows, automation, and custom system integrations across departments. Its experience with large organizations supports that operational focus. First establish whether MemberClicks Professional or Trade matches your membership model, since their capabilities differ. Include organization relationships and the optional Member App in the specific configuration you compare.
Why campai is the stronger choice for clubs with 1,000+ members.
For clubs coordinating large memberships, multiple departments, and complex workflows, campai combines experience with large organizations, advanced administration features, and integrations. Your team can automate recurring work and connect the platform to the systems your club uses.
Experience with large clubs
ALBA Berlin, a basketball club in Germany, describes working with campai since 2020. At the time of its account, the club had nearly 2,500 members and more than 150 coaches. That work brings practical experience with complex club structures.
Read ALBA Berlin’s customer storyAdvanced tools for your staff
Custom fields, roles, and access permissions help you organize responsibilities. Rules based on contact and membership data automate recurring actions, giving your staff a structured way to manage a large member base.
Explore member management and automationIntegrations and custom extensions
API access and webhooks connect other systems. Custom apps can respond to record changes or run on a schedule, supporting workflows beyond standard administration. Include configuration and any development work in your implementation plan.
Explore integrations and developer toolsProfessional and Trade require separate evaluations
MemberClicks publishes separate Professional and Trade offerings. Both list membership, events, portals, and email, while Trade also identifies advanced dues and sales management. Start with your membership structure: individual members and organization-based accounts create different requirements for records, contacts, and billing. Ask for demonstrations and a quote for the specific edition rather than combining the strongest features of the product family.
Engagement products can change the total scope
MemberClicks identifies Member App, Classroom, and CommUnity as integrated additions. The reviewed app documentation describes a separate purchase and annual billing, with connections to Trade member data and events. If these products are part of your current setup, assess their replacement or continued use separately. A core AMS price does not describe the cost of the complete member experience.
What we compared and how
We compare campai and MemberClicks across 23 selected capabilities. The selection starts with documented campai features. It is not a complete inventory of either product or a basis for an overall score.
MemberClicks Professional and Trade have different capabilities. A feature documented for one is labeled accordingly; the Member App is an optional integrated product.
Define the product scope
We distinguish product editions, plans, optional modules, and external integrations. A documented feature may cost extra and may not be available on every plan.
Connect claims to evidence
For the other provider, we use the linked product pages and help articles. For campai, we also use internal product documentation. The source register labels this first-party evidence; the related public product page provides additional context.
Separate evidence from uncertainty
A check means the capability is documented. A dash means the exact workflow is only partly documented or could not be confirmed. It does not mean the feature is missing. A cross indicates documented unavailability.
We did not measure day-to-day usability, support response times, performance under load, or the quality of an actual migration. The research date reflects the recorded evidence review. Updating the report does not mean every source was checked again.
This comparison covers US use cases. Confirm US availability, contract currency, payment options, and the scope of each module in your proposal.
Membership structure, dues rules, and member access
The matrix emphasizes records, permissions, dues, and engagement. Professional, Trade, and optional products are not assumed to have identical capabilities; read the edition and configuration qualifications attached to each finding.
Select a criterion in the table to read the explanation and its supporting sources.
| campai | MemberClicks | |
|---|---|---|
| Membership and contacts | ||
| Member and group records | ||
| Contact forms by contact type | ||
| Custom contact fields | ||
| Roles and access permissions | ||
| Saved member segments | ||
| Online membership applications | ||
| Member experience | ||
| Member profile self-service | ||
| Field-level self-service permissions | ||
| Searchable member directory | ||
| Native member app | ||
| Dues and payments | ||
| Rule-based dues calculation | ||
| Dues formulas and proration | ||
| Online invoice payments | ||
| Automatic overdue invoice reminders | ||
| Sales and workflows | ||
| Sales opportunity pipeline | ||
| REST API and webhooks | ||
| Events and resources | ||
| Built-in paid event registration | ||
| Custom event registration fields | ||
| Event attendance lists | ||
| Communication | ||
| Scheduled email campaigns | ||
| Email open and click reporting | ||
| Personalized email campaigns | ||
| Forms with confirmation emails | ||
October 20, 2026 · The comparison covers selected features, including paid plans and optional modules. A gray dash means the exact capability was not fully confirmed. External partner products are distinguished from built-in features. Each symbol includes details about scope and additional costs.
A closer look at each capability
Each criterion explains what is documented for both providers and where the evidence is limited. Source references link each claim to the material used.
Membership and contacts
Member and group records
Contact forms by contact type
Custom contact fields
Roles and access permissions
Saved member segments
Member experience
Member profile self-service
Field-level self-service permissions
Searchable member directory
Dues and payments
Rule-based dues calculation
Dues formulas and proration
Online invoice payments
Sales and workflows
Sales opportunity pipeline
Events and resources
Built-in paid event registration
Custom event registration fields
Communication
Scheduled email campaigns
Email open and click reporting
Personalized email campaigns
Name the AMS edition and every engagement add-on
Include your member count, required features, payment volume, and billing term in the same comparison.
campai
The monthly price is $40 plus $0.20 per active member. Optional setup costs $799, and training is $199 per hour. Payment processing and additional usage are billed separately.
Calculate your US priceMemberClicks
MemberClicks publishes separate annual starting prices for Professional and Trade, with final pricing based on organization and functionality needs. Request an itemized quote for your chosen AMS, implementation, payment processing, and optional products such as Member App, Classroom, and CommUnity.
Map organization relationships before changing the AMS
Discuss your switchRecord the exact MemberClicks product setup
List Professional or Trade and every connected product, including app, community, and learning tools.
Preserve membership relationships
Map organizations, individual contacts, billing responsibility, and renewal rights. Validate a representative organization after a sample import.
Recreate one complete billing and event cycle
Test the dues calculation, invoice, member registration, and related messages in the proposed configuration.
More about campai and MemberClicks.
Should I compare MemberClicks Professional and Trade as one product?
No. They have distinct scopes and pricing. Identify the edition you use or plan to buy, then check each required workflow against that edition. Findings for one should not automatically be applied to the other.
Is the MemberClicks app included with every AMS plan?
The reviewed documentation treats Member App as an additional product and describes separate annual billing. Confirm compatibility, included functions, and cost for the specific AMS edition in your proposal.
What matters when an organization is the member?
Document the relationship between the organization, its individual contacts, billing contact, and renewal rights. Test how staff and member users update those records and how dues are assigned. A flat contact import may lose relationships you need.
Sources and evidence
The numbered references connect individual claims to their sources. Provider documentation describes the offering; it does not independently establish how well it works in daily use.
Research as of:
- campai: Member management
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: Member and group records · Contact forms by contact type · Custom contact fields
Related product overview - campai: Member app
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: Member profile self-service · Field-level self-service permissions · Searchable member directory
Related product overview - campai: Dues
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: Rule-based dues calculation · Dues formulas and proration
Related product overview - campai: Payments
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: Online invoice payments · Automatic overdue invoice reminders
Related product overview - campai: Events
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: Built-in paid event registration · Custom event registration fields · Event attendance lists
Related product overview - campai: Communication
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: Scheduled email campaigns · Email open and click reporting · Personalized email campaigns
Related product overview - campai: Developer tools
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: REST API and webhooks
Related product overview - campai: Sales and sponsorship
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: Sales opportunity pipeline
Related product overview - MemberClicks platform
Public provider source · memberclicks.com
Referenced for: Automatic overdue invoice reminders
- MemberClicks pricing and product scope
Public provider source · memberclicks.com
Referenced for: Member and group records · Member profile self-service · Rule-based dues calculation
- MemberClicks Member App
Public provider source · atlas.memberclicks.com
Referenced for: Searchable member directory · Native member app
- MC Professional integration overview
Public provider source · memberclicks.com
- campai: Organization and permissions
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: Roles and access permissions
Related product overview - campai: App Store
Public provider source · apps.apple.com
Referenced for: Native member app
- campai: Google Play
Public provider source · play.google.com
Referenced for: Native member app
- campai: Forms
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: Forms with confirmation emails
Related product overview - campai: Pricing
Internal campai product documentation · First-party evidence
Referenced for: Built-in paid event registration
Related product overview - MemberClicks: expanded feature review
Public provider source · memberclicks.com
Referenced for: Roles and access permissions
- MemberClicks: expanded feature review
Public provider source · help.memberclicks.com
Referenced for: Contact forms by contact type · Online membership applications · Scheduled email campaigns
- MemberClicks: expanded feature review
Public provider source · help.memberclicks.com
Referenced for: Custom event registration fields · Event attendance lists
- MemberClicks: expanded feature review
Public provider source · help.memberclicks.com
Referenced for: Forms with confirmation emails
- MemberClicks: additional workflow verification
Public provider source · help.memberclicks.com
Referenced for: Custom contact fields · Field-level self-service permissions
- MemberClicks: additional workflow verification
Public provider source · help.memberclicks.com
Referenced for: Saved member segments
- MemberClicks: additional workflow verification
Public provider source · help.memberclicks.com
Referenced for: REST API and webhooks
Has a detail changed? Send us the criterion and the relevant provider source.
Submit a correction